Skip to content
McGrath & Spielberger PLLC
Client Reviews

1.800.481.2180

  • Contact Us
  • Home
  • Blog
  • What We Do
    • Business & Contracts
      • Choosing a Business Lawyer for NC Corporations and Other Small Business
      • The Number One Problem for Small Limited Liability Companies
      • How To Dissolve a Corporation in North Carolina?
    • Limited Liability Company
      • Your New LLC – Part 1: The Basics
      • New LLC: Maintaining Limited Liability Protection
      • Your New LLC – Part 3: Federal, State and Local Registration, Licensing and Permitting
      • “Your New LLC” – Part 4: Transacting Business in Another State
      • “Your New LLC” – Part 5: Moving Your LLC to Another State
    • Mortgage & Foreclosure
      • Hearing Results
      • Mortgage Problems – Should You Trust Your Lender or Loan Servicer?
      • When to Hire an Attorney for Foreclosure and Mortgage Relief
      • Mortgage Loans: Recourse versus Non-Recourse and Foreclosure Related Deficiency Judgments
      • Negotiating with a Bank: Why do I have to Provide My Financials?
      • Can the HOA (Homeowners’ Association) Foreclose on my Home?
    • Real Estate Cases & Closings
      • Breach of NC Real Estate Purchase Contract – Buyer’s Damages in NorthCarolina
      • Private Mortgage Insurance (PMI) – What is the Borrower Really Paying for?
    • Disputes & Lawsuits
      • Business Contracts: What Should Yours Say Regarding Recovering Attorneys’ Fees in Case of Dispute? (Part 1)
      • Business Contracts: What Should Yours Say Regarding Recovering Attorneys’ Fees in Case of Dispute? (Part 2)
      • Arbitration versus Mediation
      • Responding to a Lawsuit Complaint
    • Tax & IRS Matters
      • S-Corp Tax Election for LLC
      • Comparison of Subchapter K v. Subchapter S
      • Employment Tax Considerations in Starting a Business
      • Is your Worker an Independent Contractor? (The IRS Cares!)
    • Wills, Trusts & Estate Planning
      • Congrats, You’ve Inherited a Mess
      • When Should I Write a Will?
      • Top 5 Reasons to Change Your Will
    • Prenuptial Agreements
      • Recently Engaged? 5 Reasons Why You Should Consider A Prenup
    • Other Practice Areas
      • Indemnification in Contracts: What if Both Parties Are at Fault?
      • Indemnification in Contracts: Should You at Least Have to be Guilty as Charged?
      • Venue Clauses in Contracts – Beware Listing Only the County and State
    • Limited Scope Services
      • Arbitration Agreement: How to Get to Arbitration if A Lawsuit Was Filed First
      • Follow the Contract’s Arbitration Clause or File a Lawsuit?
      • Arbitration: setting the rules and identifying which arbitration organization will be used
  • Who We Are
    • Jason A. McGrath
    • James M. Spielberger
    • Kelly J. Brown
    • Kelly Frecker
    • Todd E. Gonyer
  • Where We Practice
  • Client Services
    • Helpful Resources
    • News & Updates
  • Consultations
  • Careers

Tuesday, February 11, 2014

Venue Clauses in Contracts - Beware Listing Only the County and State

Our law firm regularly works on business law disputes, contested real estate / mortgage loan matters, and other cases involving actual or alleged breaches of contract. We also prepare contracts for clients, of course. We know very well that a poorly drafted or inadequately considered contract increases the chances of litigation; if a party to a contract thinks the contract gives him an inch, he may very well try to take the proverbial mile.

Beware the generic venue clause! One extremely important aspect of a contract which is often overlooked as being “basic” or “boilerplate” is the designation of venue. It’s easy, right, the contract just needs to say something like (A) “Any and all claims shall be litigated in Mecklenburg County, North Carolina.” or (B) “Unless the Parties otherwise agree in writing, any lawsuit or legal claim over the subject matter of this Agreement shall be instituted and prosecuted in Charleston County, South Carolina.” Well, not so fast, my friends.[1]

I suspect that most lawyers have never considered this exact issue. Let’s take the above two examples, which use fairly ‘standard’ language with regard to venue.

(A)  “Any and all claims shall be litigated in Mecklenburg County, North Carolina.” If I’ve got a contractual dispute and the contract at issue states that venue shall be in Mecklenburg County, NC, maybe I decide to shake up the opposition by doing something unexpected . . . instead of filing in Superior Court, I file in the United States District Court for the Western District of North Carolina (Charlotte Division). After all, both courts are “in Mecklenburg County, North Carolina” even if one is a state court and the other a federal court.

(B)  “Unless the Parties otherwise agree in writing, any lawsuit or legal claim over the subject matter of this Agreement shall be instituted and prosecuted in Charleston County, South Carolina.” If my partner Jim Spielberger (who is located in Mount Pleasant, SC) is asked to advise a business owner who is expecting to be sued over an alleged breach of contract, can he, with any confidence, assure the client that the case will be in state court based on the venue clause? Could not the plaintiff, with a straight face, argue that the very language of the contract’s venue clause allows the case to be filed and litigated in the USDC for South Carolina (Charleston Federal Courthouse)? Again, this generic venue language does not specify state court or federal court.

Those of you who are dealing with venues that lack a federal courthouse may think this cannot pertain to you – and you’d be wrong, or at least potentially wrong. Some appellate decisions have held that a venue clause similar to those above would allow the case to be litigated in the federal court district which includes the named county, even if that county doesn’t have a federal courthouse / the actual federal courthouse is located in a different county.

Obviously there are other factors which influence where a case can be filed, where it should be filed, where it must be filed, etc., just as there are various elements to be considered when interpreting the language and intent of a contract. This venue designation issue can be a pit-fall for the unwary lawyer as well as the unknowing client. We have a professional obligation to be mindful of such potential problem areas and also to know when our clients may ethically and legally benefit from such loose language.



[1] Common attribution for this expression goes to Lee “Scooter” Corso, ESPN announcer and former honorable mention All-American football player for Florida State University.
at 9:00 AM
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to TwitterShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Labels: 02, Blogspot, Business Law Disputes, contracts, defendant, federal court, Jason A McGrath, jurisdiction, lawsuit, lawyer, Litigation, llc, plaintiff, state court, superior court, united states district court, venue
Newer Post Older Post Home
McGrath & Spielberger, PLLC

Tweets by JasonMcGrathLaw

Search

RECENT POSTS

  • Breach of NC Real Estate Purchase Contract - Buyer's Damages in NorthCarolina
  • Comparison of Subchapter K v. Subchapter S
  • Congrats, You’ve Inherited a Mess
  • S-Corp Tax Election for LLC
  • Jason McGrath Interviewed Regarding Internet Security for Law Firms andtheir Clients

ARCHIVES

Categories

01 02 03 04 05 06 08 09 710 form Announcements arbitration arbitration clause arbitration'contracts attending a hearing atticus finch attorney attorney fees Attorney Kelly Frecker bank of america Bankruptcy beneficiary Benefits Blogspot boa borrower breach of contract business business attorney business contracts business disputes business law Business Law & Contracts business law attorney Business Law Disputes business lawyer business owners business partners business tax buyer Cabarrus County Certificate of Existence Charlotte charlotte business journal charlotte city council Charlotte Fire Department charlotte mecklenburg police department charlotte observer CitiMortgage City of Charlotte Civil Rights civil service board claim and delivery Collections complaint construction law Consumer Defense consumer reviews consumers Continuing Series contract contract analysis contract law contracts corporate tax rate corporation court COVID-19 Credit creditor customer reviews customer satisfaction Customer Service cybercrime damages Debt debt forgiveness Deed in Lieu deed in lieu of foreclosure deed-in-lieu Deeds defendant deficiency judgments delinquent mortgage discovery Dispute dissolve Dissolve Corporation Employment employment law employment tax Estate Planning Estate Planning amp; Probate estates eviction federal court financial ratios financials florida Force Majeure foreclosure foreclosure hearing Foreclosure Hearing Results foreclosure prevention foreclosure sale foreclosures Foreclosures amp; Mortgage Loan Relief forming business fraud Freedom of Expression Freedom of Religion Freedom of Speech georgia Government hearing attendance hearing Result hoa HOA / Homeowners' Association homeowner homeowners homeowners' association income indemnification clause Inheritance intake form internal revenue code internet Internet & Technology interrogatories IRS James Spielberger Jason A McGrath Jason McGrath News / Media Jim M Spielberger jim spielberger judgment Judgments jurisdiction Kelly Brown Landlord and Tenant Landowners lawsuit lawsuits lawyer lawyers legal assistance leinholder petition lender Lenders & Mortgage Loan Servicers Lenders amp; Mortgage Loan Servicers Letter of Good Standing Life and the Law Life Planning limited liability limited liability company Litigation llc llm loan loan modification loan note loan note holder loan servicer loss mitigation lost note malpractice McGrath & Spielberger McGrath amp; Speilberger McGrath amp; Spielberger mcgrath and spielberger mediation member members mortgage mortgage dispute Mortgage Disputes mortgage insurance Mortgage lender mortgage loan mortgage loan debt mortgage loan debt income Mortgage Loan Loss Mitigation Applications Mortgage Loan Modification Mortgage Modification mortgage relief Mortgage Relief / Loss Mitigation Programs motions NASCAR Hall of Fame National Mortgage Settlement nc corporations NC Rules of Civil Procedure Necessary Knowledge negotiating negotiation newsletter non-recourse North Carolina north carolina law northa carolina oa Ohio online legal services online reviews operating agreement other-areas owner Partitions of Property partnership plaintiff PLLC PMI Power of Attorney practice of law Prenupital Agreements prenuptial agreement Private Lender private mortgage insurance Private Mortgage Insurance (PMI) profits race raleigh Real Estate recourse registered agent Reviews Roundpoint Mortgage Rushmore Rushmore Loan Management Services s corp s corporation SCRA searching for business lawyer seller series Service Contracts settlement shelby short sale short sales single member llc small business Social Media south carolina start-up business starting a business state court state law subchapter K subchapter S summary judgement summons superior court tax tax attorney tax election Tax Issues Tax Law tax rates tax-irs-matters taxes Tech Tips Tennessee The Legal Profession to kill a mockingbird trusts UCC uniform borrower assistance form united states united states district court venue video virtual law Weddings Wells Fargo Will wills wills-trusts-estate-planning-law worker classification

Sitemap

  • Contact Us
  • Home
  • Who We Are
  • Where We Practice
  • Consultations
  • Blog

What We Do

  • Business & Contract Law
  • Limited Liability Company
  • Mortgage & Foreclosure
  • Real Estate Cases & Closings
  • Disputes & Lawsuits
  • Tax & IRS Matters
  • Wills, Trusts & Estate Planning
  • Prenuptial Agreements
  • Other Practice Areas

Location

map

Directions

Contact Us

6201 FAIRVIEW RD, STE 330
CHARLOTTE NC 28210

info@mcgrathspielberger.com

1.800.481.2180

google

The attorneys responsible for this website are Jason McGrath and Jim Spielberger. At least some of the content of this website may be considered attorney advertising in some jurisdictions. For information about our website privacy policy and terms and conditions, please click here.

Attorney Website Design, Legal Search Engine Optimizations and Lawyer Online Advertising by Leads Online Marketing Services.